Sheffield Wednesday 2-1 Newcastle United: Josh Windass double gives League One side win

League One Sheffield Wednesday pulled off a memorable FA Cup shock as they knocked out the Premier League’s third-placed side Newcastle United.

Josh Windass scored twice in the second half for the Owls as they came out on top in a pulsating tie at Hillsborough.

Substitute Bruno Guimaraes gave Newcastle hope with more than 20 minutes left with a close-range finish but they could not force an equaliser.

It is the first defeat for Eddie Howe’s side since 31 August against Liverpool.

After both sides spurned good opportunities in a lively first half, Windass opened the scoring seven minutes into the second period when he finished off a flowing move.

George Byers started it with a clever turn just inside the Newcastle half before driving towards the penalty area.

He fed the ball wide to Liam Palmer, who slipped in Dennis Adeniran and his cross-shot was turned in by Windass.

The forward looked as if he may have been slightly offside but the assistant did not flag and with no VAR in operation, the goal stood.

There was nothing controversial about the second. Windass was sent clear by Michael Smith’s fine first-time pass and showed terrific composure as he opened up his body and curled the ball past Martin Dubravka into the corner of the net.

Hillsborough was bouncing but the home side’s lead was halved just four minutes later when Guimaraes, who also looked to be close to offside, stabbed in from a yard out after the Owls failed to deal with a corner.

Windass almost completed his hat-trick with a ferocious long-range free-kick that came back off the bar and although home goalkeeper Cameron Dawson made a number of vital saves, he could only watch as Chris Wood blazed Newcastle’s best chance of an equaliser over with eight minutes to go.

Owls make Magpies pay for missed chances

For a League One side to beat an in-form Premier League team – even one showing numerous changes from their usual league line-up – an element of fortune is always likely to be required.

While impressive Wednesday had plenty of the play for long periods, Newcastle will lament the opportunities they spurned.

Newcastle welcomed back record signing Alexander Isak after a hamstring injury that has kept him out since September and, while there were glimpses of the quality he possesses, there were also signs of rust.

The Sweden striker had a glorious chance to put the away side ahead and while his header from six yards out was superbly saved by Dawson, the goalkeeper ought to have been given no chance.

Josh Windass of Sheffield Wednesday scores against Newcastle United at Hillsborough
Josh Windass scored his 10th and 11th goals of the season for Sheffield Wednesday

Later in the half, he shot straight at the keeper when afforded space in the area, while Jacob Murphy should have done better when sent clear by a ball over the top.

Wood missed the best chance of the lot late on, getting his finish all wrong after being teed up by Joelinton.

Crucially, though, the Owls had the quality and determination to make the most of Newcastle’s profligacy and defended their lead valiantly to secure a famous win.


Sheff Wed

Formation 3-4-1-2

  • 25Dawson
  • 6Iorfa
  • 34McGuinness
  • 33James
  • 2PalmerSubstituted forHuntat 88′minutes
  • 14ByersSubstituted forBakinsonat 90+6′minutes
  • 4Vaulks
  • 18Johnson
  • 17Dele-BashiruBooked at 45minsSubstituted forAdeniranat 45′minutes
  • 11WindassSubstituted forWilksat 90+6′minutes
  • 24SmithSubstituted forPatersonat 88′minutes


  • 3Brown
  • 7Wilks
  • 8Adeniran
  • 13Paterson
  • 15Famewo
  • 19Bakinson
  • 31Stockdale
  • 32Hunt
  • 45Mighten


Formation 4-3-3

  • 1Dúbravka
  • 19Manquillo
  • 6Lascelles
  • 4Botman
  • 12LewisSubstituted forTrippierat 69′minutes
  • 7Joelinton
  • 36S LongstaffSubstituted forBruno Guimarãesat 60′minutes
  • 32AndersonSubstituted forWillockat 60′minutes
  • 11Ritchie
  • 14IsakSubstituted forWoodat 45′minutes
  • 23MurphySubstituted forAlmirónat 60′minutes


  • 2Trippier
  • 3Dummett
  • 20Wood
  • 21Fraser
  • 24Almirón
  • 26Darlow
  • 28Willock
  • 33Burn
  • 39Bruno Guimarães

Michael Salisbury


Live Text

Listen on Sounds bannerListen on Sounds footer